| Platinum | Wannamaker's Bakeshop |
| Gold | Dooher's Bakery |
| Silver | Sweets Bakery |
| Bronze | Sugar Mamas |
| Bronze | Tim Hortons |
| Top Pick | Country Style Donuts |
| Top Pick | Just Like Granny's |
| Top Pick | Loyalists College Market |
| Top Pick | McDowell's Your Independent Grocer |
| Top Pick | Smylie's Your Independent Grocer |
