| Platinum | Double MM Cheese Cakes |
| Gold | Wannamaker's Bakeshop |
| Silver | Cupcakes By Jen |
| Bronze | Sugar Mamas |
| Top Pick | Community BakeHouse |
| Top Pick | Just Like Granny's |
| Top Pick | Killa Cupcakes |
| Top Pick | Rachel's Tarts |
| Top Pick | Sweets Bakery |
| Top Pick | What's Your Scoop |
