| Platinum | Tomasso's Italian Grille |
| Gold | Bourbon Street Pizza Co. |
| Silver | Paulo's Italian Trattoria |
| Bronze | Jimmie's Italian Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Bosco Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Gino's Pizza / Pisano's Oldschool Belleville |
| Top Pick | Jims Greek & Italian Eatery |
| Top Pick | Linguine's Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Olympic 76 Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Tina's Pizzeria |