| Platinum | What's Your Scoop |
| Gold | Presqu'ile Park Place |
| Silver | Reid's Dairy |
| Silver | The Frozen Shoppe |
| Bronze | Dairy Queen |
| Bronze | The Tin Roof Ice Creamery |
| Top Pick | Frankford's Finest Meats |
| Top Pick | Frosty Bubble Bliss |
| Top Pick | Ivanhoe Cheese |
| Top Pick | The Scoop Shack |