| Platinum | Frankford's Finest Meats |
| Gold | Double MM Cheese Cakes |
| Gold | Maple Dale Cheese |
| Silver | Empire Cheese |
| Bronze | Cupcakes By Jen |
| Top Pick | Fifth Town Artisan Cheese Company |
| Top Pick | Ivanhoe Cheese |
| Top Pick | L'Auberge de France |
| Top Pick | Trenton Delicatessen |