| Platinum | St. Vincent de Paul Belleville |
| Gold | Belleville's Thrift Store |
| Silver | Kimberly's Deja-Vu Boutique |
| Silver | Talize |
| Silver | Value Village |
| Bronze | Mission Thrift Store |
| Top Pick | Annette's Books & Consignment |
| Top Pick | Madoc Thrift Store |
| Top Pick | The Shop |
| Top Pick | The Thrift Store Madoc |