| Platinum | Just Roll With It |
| Gold | Cupcakes By Jen |
| Gold | Killa Cupcakes |
| Silver | Cake Creations and More By Charlene |
| Bronze | Double MM Cheese Cakes |
| Top Pick | Butter Dream Cakes |
| Top Pick | Just Like Granny's |
| Top Pick | Sugar Mamas |
| Top Pick | Tasteful Trends Cafe and Cakery |
| Top Pick | Wannamaker's Bakeshop |